Saturday, September 7, 2019

3 Up, 3 Down - Who's impressed and who's underwhelmed so far this season

By Tim Sigsworth 

Here we are then. After what has seemed like less time than the forty-five minutes Kike Sola played in a Boro shirt, the first international break of the season is here.

On the face of it, Boro’s one win and six points from their opening six games (seven if you include the ignominious defeat to Crewe in the League Cup) suggests things have been far from rosy under Jonathan Woodgate.

However, Woody’s lads have improved as the season has gone on; late summer signings Marc Bola, Marcus Browne and Anfernee Dijksteel are gelling into the ranks and our attack - so often muted under Tony Pulis - is thriving despite Ashley Fletcher and Marvin Johnson playing in unfamiliar roles.

Moreover, an initially shaky and overly keen defence, along with holding midfielder Adam Clayton, appears more assured, balanced and organised than at the start of the campaign, even with Dael Fry still to get back up to full speed after injury.

As such, Boro’s start to the season has been a mixed one. Although it would have been daft to expect anything else, the players who have impressed and those who have underwhelmed nevertheless deserve analysis.

Paddy McNair

Who could have guessed that Paddy McNair would be a half-decent midfielder? Pretty much everyone bar TP, of course.

Whilst Lewis Wing has been underwhelming (more on that later), our Paddy has been a revelation since being transitioning from a right wing-back who didn’t want to play there to a centre midfielder with license to get forward.

In six successive starts, the Northern Irishman has made 220 passes at an accuracy of 81.8%, six key passes (passes or shots which directly lead to their recipient shooting) and six successful dribbles as well as scoring one goal (vs. Millwall, 24/08) and assisting another (Taylor Moore OG vs. Bristol City, 31/08).

Though his defensive responsibilities, at least in the traditional sense, have been lessened by his advanced role, McNair is required to play a major part in Boro’s smoggenpress - Woodgate’s counter-press which seeks to win the ball back as soon and as high up the pitch as possible in order to achieve numerical and positional superiority in the final third. To that end, he has made seven successful tackles (out of thirteen attempted) and six interceptions.

As the below graphic shows, his importance up and down the right-hand side of the pitch shouldn’t be underestimated, especially as his positional interchanging with the right-back (usually Jonny Howson or Anfernee Dijksteel) and right winger (typically Marvin Johnson) is central to opening up space on the right. 


Here’s to hoping he can keep up, or even improve upon, his early-season importance as the campaign goes on.

Darren Randolph

Less surprising but perhaps all the more impressive than McNair’s form is the continued brilliance of Darren Randolph.

The Irish international was one of the very few positives from last season’s torrid campaign, one which would have been infinitely worse without by his gravity-defying leaps and breezeblock shot-stopping.

Randolph has picked up where he left off in terms of his point-gaining importance to Boro’s defence, marshalling the defence with barked instructions, leading by example and making eleven saves, one of which − a left-sided leap to tip over a top-corner-bound effort from Millwall’s Ben Thompson − was truly astonishing.

Without his assuredness between the sticks, Boro’s shaky and somewhat makeshift ever-pressing back four would have undoubtedly been unable to solidify as much as it has done as the season has gone on. To that end, he is an irreplaceable figure.

Marvin Johnson

Marvin Johnson is probably one of Boro’s best examples of hindsight bias in recent seasons. Signed for £2m in 2017, he started brightly in red and white, impressing against Bolton Wanderers on his debut and at home to Queens Park Rangers a week later.

However, he soon found himself out of the first-team picture and hardly had a look in once Tony Pulis was appointed as Garry Monk’s successor in December 2017. Loaned to Sheffield United for the 2018/19 season, he was soon categorised as one of Monk’s worst signings and any sort of future at the club was widely presumed to be long gone.

His start to this season, therefore, has been almost entirely unexpected. As part of Woodgate’s unconventional forward line, Johnson has played as an orthodox winger on what is to him an unfamiliar right flank, with Britt Assombalonga through the middle and Ashley Fletcher as a false winger on the left.

But despite this apparent attacking mishmash, and although he only has one direct goal contribution to his name (assist for Ashley Fletcher’s header vs. Luton Town), the 28-year-old winger has thrived on the right-hand side of the pitch where Boro have looked so dangerous.

His positional interplay with right-sided centre midfielder McNair and right-backs Howson and Dijksteel has been central to opening up space and creating crossing opportunities for Assombalonga and late-runner Fletcher, whilst his status as the only out-and-out winger in the starting eleven has afforded him considerable importance as a direct and dynamic carrier of the ball.

Such unexpected performances have seen popular opinion of Johnson turn on its head; once a largely irrelevant footnote in the saga of how it went wrong under a certain Mr. G. Monk, he is now well aligned with Boro’s full-flow-football philosophy on the pitch and low-cost lower league recruitment policy off it.

When finally given a proper run in a stable team, he has taken his chance and established himself as one of Boro’s most influential creative players. For that, he deserves credit.

Lewis Wing

In contrast to the above, Lewis Wing’s start to the season has been unexpectedly underwhelming.

So often Boro’s only shining light in his debut season at Championship level last term, Wing was widely expected to get even better in the new attack-oriented, creative freedom-giving system.

And even though he scored an absolute howitzer against Luton and his, according to borostats.com, attacking threat score of 5.2 (how many times per game he creates a goalscoring opportunity, wins attacking ground duels or makes a pass into a dangerous position) is the second-highest in the squad (behind Fletcher’s 7.0), Wing has undeniably underwhelmed so far this campaign.

Alongside his minimal goalscoring contributions, he often appears to burn out towards the end of a game and is a less effective presser than midfield partner McNair, something probably down to a mixture of his inexperience in a role with such defensive responsibility, his deeper position in the midfield pivot and his aforementioned stamina issues.

However, he has been by no means awful and has evidently − as the stats show − been important to the team’s attacking efforts so far this season. It’s just that he could, and perhaps should, have contributed a lot more given what he managed to do last season in a far more restricted system.

Marcus Tavernier

Unlike Wing, Marcus Tavernier has hardly had the chance to make an impact for Boro this season in the 29 minutes he has played in the league. Perhaps, therefore, it is slightly unfair to include him in this list when his opportunities to make an on-pitch impact have been so few and far between.

Nevertheless, the fact that he hasn’t managed to get a look-in warrants his inclusion in my opinion.

Although Johnson, Fletcher and Assombalonga have all been in excellent form, Boro’s attacking options are limited. Marcus Browne has hardly hit the ground running, Ste Walker is young and recovering from injury and Rudy Gestede can’t be arsed.

Tav has the potential to feature on both wings and as one of the two advanced centre midfielders, but that versatility has not been utilised thus far. He doesn’t suit Fletcher’s false-winger role but there’s no reason why Fletcher couldn’t move to the right and Tavernier, or Johnson for that matter, could play as an orthodox winger on the left. His offensive attributes suit centre midfield too, but there could be some concerns about his ability to fulfil the defensive requirements of the role.

As such, his lack of involvement can probably be put down to other attackers performing well in roles − and the team system as a whole, too − where there would be some uncertainty over his ability to make an immediate and significant enough impact to warrant Fletcher, Johnson, McNair or Wing being dropped.

Tavernier, and Wing for that matter, should be by no means written off at such an early stage of the season when there will be so many more opportunities for involvement and improvement. The underwhelming thing is that he fits Woodgate’s pro-youth mantra yet has found himself out of the first-team picture.

Rudy Gestede

As touched on above, Rudy Gestede is a player who can’t wait to get away from Teesside. But only after squeezing every last penny out of his contract whilst playing as little as possible, of course.
In a squad which has shifted towards a mix of minutes-hungry youngsters and experienced grafters, Gestede is the sole mercenary outlier, a hangover from our single season of desperate Premier League gluttony in 2016/17.

His tame running, languid positioning and poor finishing have reduced his role in the squad to a mere ninetieth minute battering ram emblematic of hopeless desperation and of ‘we’ve got nowt better to do, gaffer’.

Undoubtedly one of our highest earners, his absolute lack of desire and on-pitch impact, along with his reluctance to leave for a vastly reduced salary, have left Boro burdened with a player they are unable to sell.

Because no one expects anything else from him at this point, I was half-tempted to leave Gestede off this list. But that would be doing him a service − being able to run down his contract and leave quietly through the back door is exactly what he wants.

Agree with these choices? Let us know on Twitter

0 comments:

Post a Comment